Find your peace with God.
BGEA Features

A Picture of Hope from 9/11

This Cross in Rubble Brought Peace to Ground Zero

September 6, 2011 - Anne Bybee grabbed the disposable camera she bought at a hotel gift shop and captured the moment where God brought an overwhelming sense of peace in an otherwise dark scene at Ground Zero.

A Picture of Hope from 9/11

And the peace of God, which transcends all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.
— Phil. 4:7 (NIV)

A Picture of Hope from 9/11

The rubble pile at Ground Zero was 10 stories high.

Yet nothing was identifiable.

Three weeks after the 9/11 attacks, and the scene in lower Manhattan was defined by this enormous mound of smoldering destruction.

Anne Bybee struggled to find one thing of significance.

“It was just this mangled rubble pile of nothing,” Bybee said. “I kept looking at the pile, thinking I would recognize something. A computer monitor. Or a chair. Or anything.”

Bybee was on her third day of work as part of the National Disaster Medical System (NDMS) Mission Support Team, providing logistical support to the Disaster Medical Assistance Teams (DMAT) who cared for rescue workers at Ground Zero.

Walking the Ground Zero perimeter for about 16 hours a day, she found herself almost numb. A sense of hopelessness had kicked in as she kept staring at this pile of madness.

But then, out of nowhere, she finally saw it.

'I've never seen that before'

Bybee stared at it for a few minutes. Or maybe it was an hour. She lost track of time.

She noticed a worker standing nearby and asked him a question.

“Did they do that on purpose?” Bybee said.

In his thick Bronx accent, the man quickly responded, “Yeah, they hit it with two planes.”

That wasn’t Bybee’s question.

A cross had naturally formed from the mangled remains of the Twin Towers and despite walking past this spot many times on the backside of Ground Zero, Bybee had somehow missed the imagery. (Click here to see the full frame)

As did the worker: “Oh, man, I’ve never seen that before.”

'You are not alone'

The image of the cross was more than a coincidence for Bybee, more than two fallen beams.

The voice of the Lord was speaking to her.

“As I was staring at that, I got a sense of peace,” Bybee said. “I got a very strong message. That message was ‘You are not alone. I am here.’ ”

The longer she looked at the cross, the more she was moved. There was other material wrapped around it that resembled the clothes that Jesus would have worn.

The steam in the background represented the devastation for the 9/11 families, while Bybee saw a ray of light coming in from the left, which was actually a stream of water gushing in.

“I couldn’t move for a long time,” she said. “I felt that message was not only given to me, but also to the people that I was working with and in contact with.”

'I was just speechless'

Opening the envelope from Long’s Drug Store near her home in Roseville, Calif., Bybee braced herself.

Five days earlier, she had dropped off the film to be processed. More than three weeks had passed since her encounter with the cross in the rubble.

Would the picture do it justice? Would the image be as powerful as she remembered?

Had she embellished it in her own mind?

This was a disposable camera, after all, long before digital cameras became mainstream.

“I went through the photos and was just speechless. I really was,” Bybee said. “The more you study it, the more you see.”

The iconic photo was picked up by CatholicPlanet.com, and a mega-church in Seattle used it to re-create a real-life 9/11 stage for their Easter service, which reportedly drew 25,000 people.

“I didn’t realize the photo had caught as much as it did,” Bybee said. “It brought me right back to that moment.”

'The Memory of the Smell'

Of all the images seared in Bybee’s brain from her two-and-a-half week experience at Ground Zero, the first thing that pops into her mind isn’t always this image of the cross.

In fact, sometimes it’s not an image at all.

“The memory of the smell is still with me,” she said. “That smell was constant. You knew what the smell represented.”

Bybee also thinks about the owner of the deli, who was just staring into space.

“He was just standing there and I asked if I could come in,” she recalled. “His name was Steve. He shared his story with me.”

Steve had sent all his employees home after the plane hit the first tower and shortly after that, a beam — “25 to-35 feet long” — crashed into his building.

“He said ‘What am I going to do? What am I going to do?’ ” Bybee said. “I wonder what happened to him and his business.

'So Much Has Changed'

Growing up in Nevada as the sixth of 10 children, Bybee knows a thing or two about chaos. But as an experienced Emergency Planning Analyst for the State of California, she also knows what it takes to handle an emergency situation.

Bybee is a firsthand witness of the impact 9/11 had on the nation.

“So much has changed in our country because it happened,” she said. “We are much better prepared for disaster responses than we were then.

“Every aspect from small, local communities to the Federal Government has learned from it.”

Bybee has travelled around the country giving lectures on emergency preparedness, using her 9/11 photos as training tools, especially in the years immediately following the attacks.

“Part of me felt like it wasn’t appropriate to take pictures of things I saw there,” she said. “It’s interesting, I was looking at another 9/11 presentation and so many of the pictures that are published are from a distance — the building on fire, the building collapsing, the smoke, the skyline…

“The photos that we took are literally up close and personal.”

And the photo of the cross? That’s still in her PowerPoint.

And whenever she comes across that image, Bybee pauses, if only for a second.

“I almost feel like I was a medium to capture this image,” she said.

Related Articles:

Billy Graham: A Day to Remember, A Day of Victory

Franklin Graham: Who Can Ever Forget?

Do You Need God's Love in Your Life?

Visit PeaceWithGod.net to learn about Jesus or recommit your life to Him.

 

51 Comments

diana says 12.6.2011, 08:40 a.m.

it is beautiful, i like it

Kenny says 9.26.2011, 2:16 p.m.

My sister, Anne, is my inspiration in life. She is one of the most beautiful people I know and there is no one that deserves this honor more than she does. She was there, working from dawn to dark... and beyond that, day in and day out after the tragedy of 911. This was her role in helping our nation defeat terrorism. The picture that she saw and captured in the midst of that horrible rubbish after the disaster was no accident. It was a gift that came through her, and one that gave hope where there was despair. It was also a strong message to those who caused such pain.

Becky says 9.14.2011, 02:40 a.m.

Auntie Anne, thank you for this incredible gift. You are right - how special is it that God chose you, to bring us back this message of HOPE in one of our darkest moments as a modern nation. We are blessed to have this be a lasting remembrance of all the lives who were affected in this place on Earth. Truly, you brought us back a message of peace and comfort. We are grateful!

debi says 9.13.2011, 8:00 p.m.

I see so much love it makes me remember love is all we need

Michelle says 9.13.2011, 3:18 p.m.

My parents made the RIGHT choice in making Auntie Anne my GOD-MOTHER! :) She is a beautiful woman with a LOT of wisdom! As evidenced in finding this cross among all the destruction, it is obvious she sees what nobody else can at times and makes the world a much better place by sharing her heart and experiences! It is always wonderful knowing that even when you might not have the right attitude, strength, words, ability, etc., God works through you to reach others EXACTLY as they need it! I REALLY REALLY REALLY love my Auntie Anne...Always have and always will! :)

Joe says 9.13.2011, 12:18 a.m.

Thank you so much for sharing this, and for the reminder again that God is always with us, in everything we go thru. This photo is now my desktop at work.

Anne says 9.12.2011, 10:32 a.m.

When I was contacted by BGEA asking to use my photo, I was of course honored. Never could I have known that once again the greatest blessings would come back to me in subtle ways as they did 10 years ago. First, the blessing from our Creator reminding us that we are NOT alone, regardless of the struggles in our lives. Second, the blessing of family -- my nieces and nephews have given me great joy through this connection. Finally, appreciation for the life that God has given us. When I watched the television specials yesterday (9/11) I was most moved by the children who lost a parent in this tragedy. I pray that God gives them peace in feeling the presence of their parent, always. A sincere thanks to Trevor and Tom from BGEA for using my photo and telling this story. My Mama grins from heaven. She was touched deeply by the events of 9/11 and was so proud of the work that we did there. She knew that this cross came as a gift from our Lord. Anne.

Sandra says 9.11.2011, 11:05 p.m.

What an amazing and powerful visual! I'm so thankful that God is ever present, especially in all the turmoil our society has created! Jesus Christ is our Hope and our Peace. I pray that He blesses all those who lost loved ones during 9/11 with both.

Mom says 9.11.2011, 2:18 p.m.

Thank God for the gift of Jesus Christ. God with us he is with those who trust in him thank God for this tenth year anniversary.

The McCowans says 9.11.2011, 00:21 a.m.

Love goes out to all the familys that was impacted by this day.God Bless us all

Sue says 9.11.2011, 00:15 a.m.

As the scriptures teach, " He will Bring beauty out of ashes". Only God can take a tragic situation such as this and bring good from it. The heightened awareness of God and our need to include Him in our lives was so evident in the days following 9-11. People went to church who hadn't felt the need for years! At this anniversary time may we remember our need for God.

David says 9.10.2011, 8:43 p.m.

THis is a wake up call for American all over the USA. Come to God. And repent, we must pray to God to forgive us. Are action speak for them self. 10 YEARS LATER we see the signs all around us of the coming of our lord but we keep living in the way we do.

Donna says 9.10.2011, 6:26 p.m.

On that day I was at home watching TV and I saw the first plane to hit, then the second one and of course the rest of what happened. I was there in my heart and I felt the distrubing message it was sending to me, I knew right off it was terrorists. That could not happen without it being anything else,I started to pray for all those people right then and asked God to step in and take control, he did in his own way, we do have to except death but I dont want to that way, but to get to heaven we must forgive, allthough we won't forget. God reminded us he was there with the rubble of the cross how wonderful God is.Hope and Pray you have him living in your heart today. Thank you lord for letting us serve you. AMEN

James says 9.10.2011, 4:26 p.m.

Thank you FATHER GOD and LORD JESUS for loving us all so much. Thank you for showing Ann Bybee this awsome sign and most significantly awsome testament that you FATHER GOD and LORD JESUS were there and are always with us in our lives, through the good and the devastating times. AMEN AMEN

Pat says 9.10.2011, 2:23 p.m.

God is the Everlasting GOD, He'll never change. He is GOD with us "Emmanuel"

Shannon says 9.10.2011, 12:05 a.m.

I only wish that people would realize that GOD is there always. In the good times and the bad. I have learned this more and more as I walk closer to our LORD. Blessings to all those on this 10 year anniversary. GOD is our only answer in this world.

Kim says 9.10.2011, 10:10 a.m.

Praise God for the gift of his son Jesus Christ. Thank you for always being there in all of our trials and tribulations. As we remember the events of 9/11, bless all of the families who lost their loved ones, the heroes who prevailed and those who lost their lives. Bring peace to people all over the world, knowing you are always in control no matter what the circumstances. Use this tragedy for us to come to you, praise you, and know that You are the Lord of our lives.

olie says 9.10.2011, 05:47 a.m.

That cross was a clear reminder that whatever trouble we're going through GOD always in control.

segni says 9.10.2011, 03:04 a.m.

Emmanuel.. God Is With Us!!

marie says 9.10.2011, 01:03 a.m.

Nice article, awesome picture. God Bless all those involved.

Karen says 9.9.2011, 11:47 p.m.

The evening of 9-11-2001 had the most memorable sunset looking toward Manhattan from Long Island. It had the deepest reds I have ever seen in a sunset. It seemed to pass quickly. Did anyone manage to get a photo of this moment of beauty amongst such heartbreak? The children in my neighborhood led a candlelight vigil walking through our streets that evening, praying for the families that lost loved ones, praying for those that survived. Remember to pray today for those that survived, so many saw such horror that day.

Elvis says 9.9.2011, 11:12 p.m.

HIGH RISE for 9-11 GOD BLESS OUR COUNTRY

Dixie says 9.9.2011, 8:41 p.m.

As with all of America, I thought I had seen this tragedy from all angles and to others who might think the same ~~~ I Hope You See the image of this splendid Cross ~~ a sign of Hope in the ruins, sent from God. HE will continue to show us the way. Praise His Holy Name!!

Troy says 9.9.2011, 8:30 p.m.

Auntie, you are amazing!! We are blessed to have you document such an extaordinary event and bring peace to chaos! Thank you for doing what you do!

Dian says 9.9.2011, 6:30 p.m.

This just goes to prove that God is in everything that happens good or bad. Everything is used for the betterment of His Kingdom. I praise God for what He has done and will do even on this most momentous anniversary. One day every knee shall bow and every tongue confess Jesus as Lord. I am so anxiously awaiting this day.

Sean says 9.9.2011, 5:07 p.m.

It's a pity God didn't divert the planes. At least he blessed us with some rubble shaped like a cross.

susan says 9.9.2011, 4:24 p.m.

What a reminder to me that God is with me in whatever mess I'm in, that He is faithful.

Mary says 9.8.2011, 11:47 p.m.

I love you Auntie Anne! God Bless you for the work that you do. We miss you loads!

Patti says 9.8.2011, 8:37 p.m.

HOW GREAT THOU ART; Always with us, we just have to look to see YOU.

Brian says 9.8.2011, 6:30 p.m.

Nice story. Hey, cousin Jeff, she was MY aunt first! I'll share her though, because we are all equally proud of her! Love you both. Brian

Dr. Bob says 9.8.2011, 5:55 p.m.

Anne, what a powerful and moving photo! Thank you for sharing it with us, and maybe more importantly thank you for listening to that still, small voice telling you what your eyes were seeing.......and the wits to go get a disposable camera to take a snap-shot of it. Our God who was and is and is to come is on the throne in heaven and I am convinced that neither death nor life, neither angels nor demons, neither the present nor the future, nor any powers, neither height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God that is in Christ Jesus our Lord (Romans 8:38-39)

Judi says 9.8.2011, 4:14 p.m.

Jeff is my nephew and his mother is a sister to Anne. I also have a picture of the cross that was painted by Jeff's mother and also a copy of the bookmark that she emailed me. How the cross can be so beautiful and yet so tragic. My heart goes out to all of the people and their families in such a disaster. 911 will be remembered forever.

carol says 9.8.2011, 3:58 p.m.

Absolutely breathtaking and peaceful!!!

jeff says 9.8.2011, 3:25 p.m.

That is my aunt, and she rocks. My mom has painted that picture and sent it to me. I am honored to know first hand someone who went to help in this tragedy. Love ya Auntie Anne

Budge says 9.8.2011, 1:22 p.m.

Everything starts and ends at the foot of the Cross!

Michael, Boston, MA, USA says 9.8.2011, 1:10 p.m.

Until we as a nation begin to CORPORATELY lift up the blood stained banner of Jesus Christ far above the Star Spangled banner, ......then shall righteousness dwell in our fruitful fields and our fruitful fields shall be counted for a forest and then the works of righteousness shall be PEACE and the effects of righteousness shall be QUIETNESS AND ASSURANCE FOREVER and my people shall dwell in PEACEABLE HABITATIONS.

Moffat Wanjiru(kmoffats) says 9.8.2011, 12:29 a.m.

In every desert of calamity God brings an oasis of comfort. Even in the very times of hopelessness, in silence, doubts, anguish, and even blood spilled all over, God was still speaking to one soul that would otherwise speak to the world.

sherrill says 9.8.2011, 11:21 a.m.

To me, this picture says; The cross will ALWAYS stand! A message that no matter what people mandate re; prayer, trying to push God out of His creation...I will glory in the cross, for it is the power of God unto salvation. Hallelujah! Glory to Jesus for the unsearchable depths of the Love of God the Father, who gave His ONLY begotten Son. Praise you Lord of Lords...King of Kings!

Jeremiah says 9.8.2011, 11:09 a.m.

Am in Uganda but my prayers are with you America, God bless.

Janaína says 9.8.2011, 11:04 a.m.

There is always hope in Jesus Christ!

Belen says 9.8.2011, 10:57 a.m.

I would like to say that God is everything in this life, He is the answer to all our problems, He is the father of the whole world, if only everybody could understand it then maybe we would all live in harmony and peace, Why can't people see that there is only one God, one Father and the Lord of Lord's. I thank God I know him and without Him I cannot see ahead in the future, Thank you Jesus for coming into my life, I would never ever want to live without You.

Ethel says 9.8.2011, 10:56 a.m.

God is with us, now and always. Please pray that we stop pushing Him away, rather, that we draw Him closer. Thank you!

Debbie says 9.8.2011, 10:54 a.m.

That wonderful cross being formed from such devastating debris can only be a sign from God. I'm sure it brings hope and comfort to everyone who sees it. I had no personal ties with any 9/11 victims or their families, but I felt their pain and sorrow. I'm so glad this cross was captured by Ms Bybee and can be shown to so many people. By her hard work and dedication and love of humanity, she is truly an inspiration to us all.

Rhoda says 9.8.2011, 10:42 a.m.

Like...A very moving experience.

Peggy says 9.8.2011, 10:23 a.m.

Gloryyyyyyyyyyyyyy Be to God!!!!!!!!!

Susan says 9.8.2011, 10:07 a.m.

God always find ways to let people with no faith and those who have faith knows he exists. I remember people were going back to church after this horrible incident. Thank God for Christians in America!

Buddy says 9.8.2011, 10:04 a.m.

And thus a campaign to keep that cross at the 9/11 rages on to this day. My hope is that it would stay there, even though Satan's crew is trying to take it out of there, saying it is unconstitutional. I believe in the Cross, I believe in Jesus. Pray for this piece of historical significance stays in the memorial to show that God is STILL here.

Letha says 9.8.2011, 10:01 a.m.

I would like to say that your article was very touching and YOUR work after the 9/11 attack on OUR country is very much appreciated by me and thousands of others. Our prayers go out to you and all others that helped and prayed. I was standing in my living room that day, my Pastor and husband were in the yard talking. I called them in to see what was happening, then the buildings started to crumble. I cannot even imagine in my wildest dreams what those people were thinking or going through. But I know Our Lord and Savior was there. Thank you again for this article, it brings me back to that day, with heart felt compassion. GOD BLESS YOU AND GOD BLESS THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.

Helen says 9.8.2011, 09:22 a.m.

I feel wonderful after reading and seeing the photo. I know there is a God and I believe in him. The photo reminds me of no matter what happens Christ is always with us.

Debbie- Ohio says 9.8.2011, 09:15 a.m.

I am so moved by this mangled cross figure, it's a Huge reminder that God was there that day and is always there for us, no matter what happens in our lives. Thank you so much for sharing this image, it will stay with me for forever, I will remember that God sent this cross to remind us of his love for us in the midst of this rubble of the twin towers. God is awesome and worthy of our praise! Thank you Jesus for loving all of us enough to show us at times like this.

cathy says 9.8.2011, 09:12 a.m.

I was there on 10/15/01. I went with a small team from my church,Calvary chapel, Philadelphia. We were the second team of many that went up. I remember walking around Ground Zero for hours and hours talking and listening to the soldiers, police officers, firemen, sanitation workers and anyone who needed an ear. We prayed with them, cried with them and talked about Jesus and his love for them. I was truly humbled by my experience there and forever changed. I and many others from my church continued to go up during the 7-8 months it took to clean up. We got involved with the Salvation Army and served food, witness, and just listened at the huge tent and at St. Joes. Many attended church services at the foot of the steel cross. I will never forget the smell either, it was gritty,pungent and unforgettable. One thing was for sure, Jesus was there every second of every minute. He guided us to those that needed him most. He comforted us, protected us, and gave us the hope we needed to share with the hurting. I am forever His and look forward to seeing Him face to face. Thank you Jesus for letting me serve you!

Post a Comment

BGEA encourages you to participate in this discussion; however, please be aware that your comment will not appear immediately. Also be aware that we reserve the right to edit comments for spelling, grammar and clarity. User comments that include personal attacks or other inappropriate comments will not be approved for posting. Thank you for your patience.

Thank you for commenting on this article. Although you won't see your comment immediately, it will appear after a moderation process is completed. We appreciate your feedback.

© 2013 BILLY GRAHAM EVANGELISTIC ASSOCIATION. BGEA IS A REGISTERED 501(c)(3) NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATION.PRIVACYFacebookTwitterYoutubePinterest